"I Have a Dream"
by Kate McLaughlin (aka Carrol
Grady)
Simply expressed, my dream is that we will learn
to view our church as a hospital for sinners, rather than a club for
saints. When Jesus said, "I have not come to call the righteous, but
sinners," he knew that all were sinners . . . but those who thought
they were righteous did not recognize their need.
In terms of our sons and daughters who are homosexual, this is how my
dream translates;
"First of all, we need to patiently and perseveringly continue to
educate those who have no understanding of the complexity of
homosexuality. When I recall my ignorance and prejudice before learning
about our son, I cannot judge those who show the same ignorance and
prejudice today because they have never had to face this situation in
their own lives. We can only bring about change through a spirit of
Christian love for all. . . .
My dream is that someday our church will have the courage and
compassion to come forward and make a forthright, public,
"official" statement such as the American Catholic bishops did
recently (printed in the Nov-Dec 1997 newsletter), acknowledging that
homosexual orientation is not a choice, that God does not love anyone less
because they are homosexual, and, even while recognizing that homosexual
behavior is not God's plan, urging parents (and all church members) to
accept and love their gay children in a world where they face rejection on
every hand. We cannot totally blame church members who express bigotry and
hatred, when the church has "officially" remained silent
regarding this issue. And this kind of public acknowledgment would help
enable parents just learning of their child's homosexuality to respond in
a more loving, redemptive way and eliminate some of the wounds that can
occur in the early states of adjustment, through ignorance and wrong
perceptions."
Although many of our sons and daughters have left the church, there are
far more than most might think who quietly remain in the church. I believe
that a large number follow a celibate lifestyle and keep their orientation
a secret. How much brighter and happier their lives might be if they felt
free to admit that they face a daily struggle with their sexual desires,
if other church members would support them with love and prayer, would
offer them the non-sexual intimacy of close friendship to fill their need
of belonging to a group so they no longer feel isolated and alone. What a
blessing they could be to the church if they were encouraged to use the
considerable talents, with which most of them are gifted, in service to
god! What a help this would be to them if they could express their
sublimated sexual desires through creative enhancement of the worship we
offer god. I believe there are many others who might perhaps be drawn and
encouraged to make the kind of sacrifice celibacy demands if they
perceived this kind of warm, caring atmosphere in our church.
My dream extends to the plight of young teenagers just beginning to
recognize their difference. I think most of us have felt the regret of nut
understanding what our child had to go through alone, the pain of
realizing our ignorance of the teasing and harassment they suffered from
their peers. How much it might help them (and their peers) to accept
themselves if an understanding, non-judgmental attitude toward homosexuals
could be taught in our schools. Imagine a teacher telling a class of 7th
and 8th graders, "Because we live in a fallen world where Satan has
tried in every way to undermine God's perfect plan for us, some people are
apparently born with an attraction to others of the same sex, the way most
of us are born with an attraction to the opposite sex. Some of you may
discover that you have these homosexual attractions. it is not a
sin to have these feelings over which we have not control. Those of us who
do not have such feelings should not look down on those who do. Each one
of us has some sinful tendency with which we must struggle, and we need to
show love, support and encouragement to each other, instead of
condemnation and prejudice. If any of you have questions about this I will
be glad to talk to you about them." I think that, over time, this
kind of openness and matter-of-fact acceptance would remove much of the
frustration and negative self-image that plagues boys and girls as they
are learning to deal with their homosexuality and would help heterosexual
young people be more understanding.
And what of the many men and women, our sons and daughters, who have
been so hurt by the rejection and prejudice they have encountered that
they have left the church? What of those who, in the frustrating challenge
of trying to understand themselves and God's plan, have come to believe in
a different interpretation of the bible? Should not our church extend
God's (and our) love and compassion to them also? Are they not in a much
need of God's love and grace as any of us? If they want to be part
of our church, should we turn them away? The bible tells us frankly that
Jesus associated with sinners -- drunkards and gluttons, tax collectors
and prostitutes. While we might not class our beloved children with such a
company, there are surely those who would. If we are ever going to follow
Jesus' example, we must learn to extend our love and acceptance to
everyone who enters our church doors. if this goes against the grain of
the way we have been taught to think, perhaps we need to challenge that
kind of thinking. I am not advocating abolishing the high principles by
which God calls us to live our lives, but I don't believe their attainment
should be considered a prerequisite for "belonging to the club."
Each of us has some area in which we struggle with temptation, in which
our victories alternate with defeat. And no doubt each of us has some sin
in our lives, visible to others, of which we are not yet aware. God does
to ask us to judge the worthiness of our progress of others. But I believe
he does call us to love others as he loves us. I believe an attitude of
understanding, compassion, and respect for each individual as a beloved
and valuable child of god will go a long way toward healing past wounds.
This, then is my dream -- a church where love,
affirmation, acceptance and encouragement is extended by all, to all; a
hospital where all recognize that they are sinners in need of healing by
the Divine Physician."
While Jesus was having dinner at Matthew's house, many tax
collectors and sinners came and ate with him and his disciples. When the
Pharisees saw this, they said to his disciples, "Why does your
teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?" On hearing this, Jesus
said, "It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. But go
ad learn what this means: 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' For I have not
come to call the righteous, but sinners." Matthew 9:10-13